Our Response to the USPSTF Recommendation
Posted by Nathan Switzer on Thu, Nov 19, 2009
This past Tuesday, November 17 new recommendations by the US Preventive Services Task Force rolled out. The Task Force took a "new" look at existing data, and made a recommendation to drastically change screening mammography guidelines. Instead of beginning at age 40, the Task Force stated that women should wait until 50 for their initial mammogram, unless they are high risk. Additionally, they recommend screening every other year, and that all screening stops at age 75.
Dr. Denise Farleigh, medical director of Providence Imaging Center (PIC), makes the following initial statement regarding the Task Force's announcement:
"The American Cancer Society, the American College of Radiology and the Society of Breast Imaging have already issued formal statements that express their opposition to the revised guidelines presented by the Task Force. I am in agreement with their comments, many of which can be viewed in the links below.
The ‘new' recommendations are irresponsible and dangerous, and will cost many women their lives if followed," emphasizes Dr. Farleigh.
"We are at risk to reverse the downward trend in the death rate from breast cancer in this country which is due in large part to screening with mammography, along with more effective treatment. The woman in her forties has a one in 69 chance of developing breast cancer, and delayed diagnosis will contribute to increased morbidity from treatment as well as an increase in deaths from the disease.
In summary, PIC will continue to recommend screening for women over the age of 40."
Here are links to some initial responses nationwide:
STATEMENT FROM THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF RADIOLOGY AND THE SOCIETY OF BREAST IMAGING:
USPSTF Mammography Recommendations Will Result in Unnecessary Breast Cancer Deaths Each Year
Detailed ACR Statement on Ill Advised and Dangerous USPSTF Mammography Recommendations
American Cancer Society Statement
Susan G. Komen Screening Statement 11-16-09
Health & Human Services Secretary Sebelius Statement on New Breast Cancer Recommendations - 11-19-09